Investors Weigh the Effect of the Economic War on Russia

Taking stock

As severe sanctions against Russia take shape, economists, executives and investors around the world are trying to gauge the effects. Europe and its allies will wage “total economic and financial war,” Bruno Le Maire, France’s economy minister, said today. “We are going to cause the Russian economy to collapse.”

Markets have been volatile, but the moves in some global benchmarks have been more muted than one might expect. The S&P 500 appeared headed for a major fall yesterday, but ended down less than a quarter of a percent. (Futures suggest U.S. markets will open lower again today.) And investors have been seeking safety in bonds, pushing down yields to where they were about a month ago.

Investors are weighing the long-term implications of the sanctions, which are designed to undermine the ruble and limit Russia’s ability to reverse the damage. Experts said the sanctions were based on lessons that the U.S. and its allies learned from 2014, when Russia occupied Crimea and the West’s financial punishments proved an ineffective deterrent.

• Elina Ribakova, the deputy chief economist at the Institute of International Finance, called the sanctions “serious” and predicted Russia’s economy could contract by double digits.

• Others were more skeptical, saying that carve-outs for oil and gas exports would prop up Russia’s economy. “The devil is in the details of how sanctions are enforced,” Juan Zarate, a former assistant secretary of the Treasury for terrorist financing and financial crimes.

For all the damage of the sanctions, the fact is that Russia’s economy is not that big, accounting for a few percentage points of global output. (The Russian economy was a much bigger piece of the world economy during its 1998 financial crisis.) Still, the sanctions will have a noticeable impact on commodities where Russia is a key producer, including wheat, corn and metals like palladium and nickel. Airspace closures mean that shipping rates could jump, too. Major western multinationals generate a small share of their earnings in Russia (outside of the energy sector — more on that below). “The damage is likely to be small,” Adam Posen, the president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics, said of the sanctions and the global economy.

The big picture: Investors face geopolitical risks largely ignored since the Cold War. This adds to the fears over China’s worsening relations with the West and its crackdown on companies and Hong Kong. Mark Haefele, the chief investment officer of UBS’s wealth management division, noted in a report to clients yesterday that market sell-offs “linked to geopolitical turmoil tend to be short-lived.” But as any experienced investor knows, past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Further reading:

• Fiona Hill, the Russia expert who has worked as an analyst in Democratic and Republican administrations, has a sobering view of the conflict: Asked whether Putin would use nuclear weapons, she told Politico, “Well, yes, he would. And he wants us to know that, of course.”

• Citigroup said it had nearly $10 billion in total exposure to Russia as of year end, some of which it may be stuck with because of sanctions.

• More companies and entities suspended ties to Russia: Disney and Warner Bros. suspended theatrical movie releases there; Netflix said it won’t carry 20 state-run propaganda channels; and FIFA effectively banned Russia from this year’s World Cup.

• Crypto investors have donated $22 million so far to the Ukrainian government and a nonprofit supporting its military.

• A Ukrainian yacht mechanic confessed that he tried to sink the boat owned by his boss, who he claimed was a Russian arms dealer.

HERE’S WHAT’S HAPPENING

President Biden prepares to defend his economic record. Tonight, in his first State of the Union address, Biden is expected to take credit for a robust economic recovery, even as he also addresses inflation and urges Congress to adopt parts of his stalled social and economic spending plan.

Supreme Court justices appear skeptical of the E.P.A.’s climate authority. At a hearing yesterday, several of the court’s six conservatives questioned the extent of the agency’s ability to regulate emissions from power plants. Limiting the E.P.A.’s powers could curb the Biden administration’s ability to fulfill its climate pledges.

More pandemic restrictions are lifted. California, Oregon and Washington will lift school mask mandates on March 11, while the White House will end mask requirements for fully vaccinated visitors.

Investors sour on Zoom — again. Shares in the videoconferencing company fell after it disclosed another quarter of slowing sales growth and a gloomier-than-expected forecast for its next quarter. It’s the latest sign that investor favorites from earlier in the pandemic are falling out of favor as the economy reopens.

A crypto entrepreneur is charged with running a $2.4 billion Ponzi scheme. Federal prosecutors accused Satish Kumbhani, who founded the now defunct BitConnect exchange, of defrauding customers who used his company’s “lending program.” Separately, Heather Morgan, half of the married couple accused of trying to launder billions in stolen Bitcoin, is negotiating a potential plea deal.

Serena Williams raises $111 million for new venture fund

Serena Williams’s early-stage venture capital firm, Serena Ventures, has raised an inaugural fund of $111 million that will invest in founders with diverse points of view, Williams told DealBook. The investment firm led by the tennis star, which will invest in pre-seed through Series A rounds, is already an active angel investor with a portfolio of 60 companies that include SendWave, MasterClass and Daily Harvest.

“I’ve always been fascinated with technology and I’ve always loved how it really shapes our lives,” said Williams, who has been investing for nine years. “When I met my husband, that was our first conversation. That’s how we met. I was talking about investments.” (Williams’s husband is the Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian.)

Williams was inspired by a talk between Caryn Seidman-Becker and Jamie Dimon. Onstage at an event, Seidman-Becker, the C.E.O. of the security company Clear, said that less than 2 percent of venture money goes to women. “I go up to her afterward and asked, ‘Tell me about this 2 percent — I know maybe you misspoke,’” Williams recounted. “And she says, ‘No, it’s true.’ And I literally couldn’t wrap my mind around the fact that 98 percent of all of this money we’re talking about — billions of dollars — goes to one type of individual.” Serena Ventures doesn’t require that its founders come from historically underrepresented backgrounds, though it says 76 percent of its portfolio company founders do.

The founding partners of Serena Ventures are Williams and Alison Rapaport Stillman. Beyond her 23 Grand Slam tennis titles, Williams’s other business activities include fashion lines, entertainment deals and serving on the board of Poshmark. Rapaport Stillman previously worked at JPMorgan Chase, Wasserman and Melo7 Tech. The fund’s limited partners include Norwest, Capital G (Alphabet’s growth fund) and LionTree.

---

“Would you like to sign in with your palm?”

— The Times’s Cecilia Kang visits a prototype Whole Foods store in Washington, which Amazon has packed with cameras and sensors that track shoppers in order to charge their account as they leave the store, skipping a cash register — and most human contact.

---

The latest on Big Oil and Russia

Shell said yesterday it would exit its joint ventures with Gazprom, the Russian energy group, a day after BP said it would sell its stake in Rosneft, the Russian state-controlled oil company. Shell and BP are likely to take financial hits worth billions of dollars as a result of the sales.

The moves highlight the pressure that Western energy companies are under to cut their exposure to Russia as sanctions isolate it financially and diplomatically. But who will buy these divestments? At what price? (Relatedly, who will advise the sellers on offloading the stakes — and at what price?)

Here is where the oil majors stand:

BP said Sunday that, along with divesting its nearly 20 percent stake in Rosneft, its C.E.O., Bernard Looney, and his predecessor, Bob Dudley, have also resigned from the Russian company’s board. BP’s stake in Rosneft accounts for about one-third of its reported oil and gas production and a substantial share of its profits. BP reportedly considers a steeply discounted sale to Rosneft itself as the best option.

Shell said yesterday that it would exit four joint ventures that it has with Gazprom and its subsidiaries. Shell is also pulling out of an oil joint venture called Salym IV, as well as ending its involvement with the Nord Stream 2 pipeline. Shell said it would take an unspecified write-off from the divestments, but also said it planned to increase its dividend and continue with share buybacks.

TotalEnergies said today that it would no longer invest in new projects in Russia, a move that doesn’t go as far as its rivals. The French company owns about 19 percent of Novatek, a Russian gas company, and a minority stake in a $27 billion natural gas export facility called Yamal LNG. Giacomo Romeo, an analyst at Jefferies, said supplies from the Yamal venture are vital to Total’s gas business.

Exxon Mobil has produced oil for a quarter-century from the same area as Shell. How Exxon handles its Russian exposure represents one of its biggest tests since Engine No 1, a socially conscious activist investor, won three board seats last year. But compared with its rivals, Exxon’s exposure to Russia is small — only around 2 percent of its total global oil flow. That could make it easier for Exxon to divest its holdings (or deflect attention to what the other oil majors are doing in Russia). Exxon’s share price, unlike those of its peers, has risen in recent days.

THE SPEED READ

Deals

• TD Bank agreed to buy First Horizon, a Tennessee-based lender, for $13.4 billion, its biggest-ever takeover. (WSJ)

• The F.T.C. is reportedly weighing a lawsuit to block Amazon’s $8.5 billion takeover of MGM. (The Information)

• Derek Jeter stepped down as C.E.O. of the Miami Marlins and sold his stake in the pro baseball team. (NYT)

• Neil Diamond joined a growing list of musicians in selling his entire song catalog — yes, including “Sweet Caroline” — for millions. (NYT)

Policy

• Hacks by Russia amid the Ukraine invasion are testing Washington’s ability to work with tech giants on cyberdefense. (NYT)

• Pension funds are the latest to struggle with rapidly rising inflation. (WSJ)

• Richard Blum, a financier and major political donor and the husband of Senator Dianne Feinstein, died on Sunday. He was 86. (NYT)

Best of the rest

• In a new memoir, the financier Bill Gross says he was fired from Pimco for cursing out his then-boss. (NY Post)

• In a battle over bling, Cartier sued Tiffany & Company for stealing “high jewelry” trade secrets. (Bloomberg)

• A fascinating analysis of what avoiding Russian airspace means for airlines. (@thatjohn)

We’d like your feedback! Please email thoughts and suggestions to [email protected].